Archival Notice
This is an archive page that is no longer being updated. It may contain outdated information and links may no longer function as originally intended.
(Citation: "Deposing an Adverse Witness," by Clifford L. Somers. For the Defense 31(7) (July 1989): 24-29. Courtesy of Defense Research Institute. Used with permission. Cited from: Succeeding as an Expert Witness, 3rd ed., 2000, Appendix 1.13: 230-234.)
The following outline was prepared for deposing attorneys and is intended as an aid in taking the deposition of an adverse expert. Attorneys are advised to consider it as a guide, not as a script. This outline may be useful to the expert preparing for deposition as an example of the depth, detail, and degree of specific questioning he or she might expect from opposing counsel:
I. Background and Qualifications
A. Accomplishments: resume, curriculum vitae, bibliographies and lists of presentations.
B. Education and Training
- What schools or training courses has the expert attended?
- What on-the-job training was received?
- What degrees or certificates were obtained, and when?
- What licensing, specialty certification, or other professional accreditation was received, from whom and when?
- Have the expert's accreditations ever been questioned, investigated, suspended or removed?
- Has the expert ever been sued as a result of professional activities?
C. Litigation Experience
- 1. Has the expert testified in a lawsuit before?
- Where, when and how often?
- How much of the witness's income is derived from testifying or preparing to do so?
- Does the expert advertise his or her services? If so, where and when?
- How did the witness get into this case?
- Has the witness ever served for this lawyer or his or her firm, and how often?
D. Publications
- Has the expert ever published any original work on the subject of this lawsuit?
- Review the expert's bibliography and presentations with him or her as to their bearing on the current action.
E. Research
- Has the witness ever done research relevant to the subject at issue?
- If so, when, where, under what circumstances, and for whom (provide details).
- Were the results published? If so, where can you get a copy?
F. Professional Organizations
- For a physician, membership on hospital staffs.
- For all experts, membership in organizations (current or past positions).
- Have they ever had their privileges or memberships questioned, investigated, suspended or removed? Get details.
I. Materials Provided
A. Records
- Do you have a complete list?
- From what source were they derived?
- Are they copies? If so, from what source were they copied?
- Is the witness expecting to examine more records? If so, what records, when and from where?
- Were there any records the witness wanted but did not receive?
B. Literature, Tables and Standards
- From what precise source were they obtained?
- Who obtained them?
- Were copies retained by the witness?
- s this material authoritative, useful, persuasive, and generally relied on in the industry?
- Is the expert aware of any literature that is relevant but still in preparation or in the process of being published? Get details.
C. Oral Information
- From whom was the information obtained and when?
- What information was obtained?
- What part did the information play in the witness's activities?
- What notes or records were made of the oral information, and where are these?
D. Other Materials
- What other materials or information were gathered and used?
- When, where, and from whom were they obtained? Where are these materials now?
- Is anything else expected? If so, what, when and from whom?
III. The Task of the Expert Witness
A. What Was the Task?
- Has the expert ever done this task before? Get details.
- Did they do what they were asked to do in this case?
- Did they do anything beyond what they were asked to do?
B. Standards
- What is your definition of "standard of care?"
- In this case, how do you know what the standard is?
- Describe any field experience you may have in practicing under these standards.
- If the standards are derived from a publication, which one specifically?
- f there are governmental or industry standards, did you help to prepare such standards? Give relevant details.
IV. Who Gathered Information for the Expert?
A. Did you personally do all the work that led to your opinions?
B. Give full names, addresses, titles, and qualifications of others involved in gathering and evaluating data.
C. What did each of these people do?
D. Were you actively involved in their work or did you supervise?
E. Were you present at all times while the others performed their work?
F. Give full names, addresses, titles, and qualifications of any independent consultants whose input was received.
G. What did they produce?
H. How was it used?
I. Explore qualifications and hearsay problems.
V. Terminology
A. All non-lay terms of any complexity or strangeness must be defined.
B. Never forget that the jury may not know a term that you are familiar with.
C. Never fear appearing ignorant. Require the expert to explain, in simple language, all technical terminology.
VI. Resources and Background Research
A. Records Reviewed
- Describe the time spent and the thoroughness of your review.
- What part did records play in the formation of opinions?
B. Technical Publications
- How were manuals and other technical publications obtained?
- Do you have copies?
- What part did the publications play in the formation of opinions?
C. Products
- Who examined or worked on the products at issue?
- What was done with or to the products?
- What were the findings?
- What is the significance of the findings?
- Were photographs, microscope slides, videotapes, X-rays, or other pictorial or graphic records made?
- Who has these visual records?
- What do they demonstrate?
D. Computers
- Describe the types of computers used in gathering and analyzing the information.
- Who used the computers?
- What special software was used?
- What was done with the computers?
- Do you have copies of any printouts of results?
- How did the results affect the expert's opinions?
E. Other Equipment
- Describe all scientific or technical equipment used in gathering and analyzing the information.
- Was the equipment calibrated? If so, when and how?
- Who operated the equipment, and what did he or she do?
- What were the results? 5. Where are the results recorded?
- How did the results affect the expert's opinions?
F. Other Testing
- What was done?
- Who did it?
- What were the results?
- How did the results affect the expert's opinions?
VII. Opinions
A. List the Opinions Reached
- 1. Have the witness list each professional opinion or category of opinion reached.
- Read the list of opinions aloud to check for accuracy.
- Get agreement from the witness that you have a complete and accurate list.
B. Facts
- With respect to each opinion, get a recitation of the operative facts on which it is based.
- f it is not stated or clear, get a citation to the source of each fact.
- Get a list of any assumptions made about the facts.
- State the basis of the assumptions.
- Make the witness agree that you have all the relevant facts for each opinion.
C. Reasoning For each opinion, get an explanation of the reasoning process from facts to conclusions.
D. Causal Relationships
- For each opinion, get an explanation of its causal or other relationship to the case.
- Get an explanation of the interrelation of multiple factors.
E. Standards
- Are the opinions based on proper industry or professional standards?
- Would the majority of the expert's peers agree with the stated opinions?
- Are there any respected minority opinions in the field?
- Does the witness concede the legitimacy of minority or differing views in the field?
VIII. Concluding Questions
A. Other Work
- What additional responsibilities or participation does the expert expect to undertake in this case?
- When will it be done?
- If nothing more is to be done, does the witness feel that what was done is a sufficient basis for the opinions rendered?
B. Have all of the witness's professional opinions or conclusions in this case been explored in the deposition?
- If not, what else is there? Follow up as above.
- Does the witness feel that he or she has had a fair chance to state these other opinions or conclusions?
- s there anything the witness would like to add so as not to be misunderstood?