U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

Democrats have shut down the government. Department of Justice websites are not currently regularly updated. Please refer to the Department of Justice’s contingency plan for more information.

"Factor of Two" Issue in Mixed DNA Profiles

NCJ Number
249416
Date Published
December 2014
Length
7 pages
Annotation
This study explored how the likelihood ratio (LR) for any mixture can be constructed to report correctly at the sub-source level by taking contributor orders and genotype set orders into account; worked examples of the LR calculation are included to assist in explaining this confusing issue.
Abstract
A commonly used idea in forensic fields is known as the ‘hierarchy of propositions’. DNA analysts commonly report at the sub-source level in the hierarchy. This means that they simply comment on the probability of the evidence for the given propositions that consider contributors that lead to a DNA profile and not on the source of specific biological components, not the activity that led to the transfer or the offense that is reported to have occurred; however, DNA analysts also commonly report at a level even lower than the sub-source level. In this ‘sub–sub-source’ level only reference comparisons to components of a mixture are reported. The difference between the sub-source level and sub–sub-source level is the difference between comparing an individual to a mixture as a whole, or comparing them to only one component of a mixture. This idea has been expressed in the past as the ‘two trace’ problem or the ‘factor of two’ problem. With the advent of expert systems that can provide a measure of weight of evidence in the form of a likelihood ratio (LR) for any mixture, resolvable or not, the distinction between these two levels becomes more important. (Publisher abstract modified)

Date Published: December 1, 2014