This study analyzes the deterrent effect of prosecuting domestic violence misdemeanors.
The deterrent effect of arrest on domestic violence has been well researched. However, the effect of arrest should be examined within the context of whether and how cases are prosecuted and sanctions imposed. The study analyzed rearrest as a function of court disposition in a sample (n = 1,133) of domestic violence misdemeanor cases. There was no effect of disposition on rearrest within a 6-month period. The likelihood of recidivism was indistinguishable for cases resulting in nolles, dismissals, probation with batterer treatment program, and jail sentences. The article concludes that, because habitual behavior occurs in the privacy of people's homes and out of the public eye, much of it is likely to be highly resistant to change. The criminal justice system has an important role in protecting victims from abuse by more powerful persons, but criminal justice intervention is not always the controlling factor in interpersonal relationships governed by complex forces. Table, references
Downloads
Related Datasets
Similar Publications
- Extending the Discussion on Inconsistency in Forensic Decisions and Results
- Examining Radicalization's Risk and Protective Factors: A Case-Control Study of Violent Extremists, Non-Violent Criminal Extremists, Non-offending Extremists & Regular Violent Offenders
- Adolescent Weapon Carrying Inside and Outside of School: The Impact of Experiences and Perceptions of Violence