U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

Decision theory and linear sequential unmasking in forensic fire debris analysis: A proposed workflow

NCJ Number
304971
Journal
Forensic Chemistry Volume: 29 Dated: July 2022
Author(s)
F. A. Whitehead; M. R. Williams; M. E. Sigman
Date Published
July 2022
Annotation

This report introduces a new workflow that extends the data analysis and interpretation methods of ASTM E1618-19, in which the fire-debris analyst presents the fire-debris report in categorical terms, with the possibility of introducing disclaimers.

Abstract

The ASTM E1618-19 standard method for fire debris analysis does not endorse the use of statistical analysis to establish error rates or the use of probabilistic statements about the strength of the evidence. In the new proposed workflow, analysts are asked to assign evidentiary values to fire debris samples. The assigned values are combined with decision theory to determine an optimal decision threshold for ascribing a sample as positive or negative for ignitable liquid residue in categorical terms. The new workflow incorporates linear sequential unmasking with the data analysis methods of ASTM E1618-19, machine learning likelihood ratios and the use of ignitable liquid and substrate databases. The workflow is applied to 20 known ground truth samples by each of three analysts to generate validated personal receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves and optimal decision thresholds. The ROC curve provides a direct link between perceived evidentiary value and decision thresholds based on a defined ratio of costs for false positive and false negative decisions. The new workflow is applied to casework-relevant large-scale burn data for which the ground truth is unknown. (Publisher abstract provided)

 

Date Published: July 1, 2022